“Free from” and “with” claims in cosmetics: what is allowed
Updated: 4 hours ago
“Paraben-free”, “sulfate-free”, “with aloe vera”, “enriched with vitamin E”: these small statements sell. They are also among the most frequently checked by the authorities, because they go straight to consumer trust.
A claim is never free. It must meet the six common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, and article 20 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 prohibits attributing to a cosmetic characteristics it does not have. Rather than a long explanation, here are concrete cases, followed by the method to validate your own wording.
Ten statements under the microscope
Statement | Verdict |
“Paraben-free” | Avoid. It implies that authorised parabens are dangerous: this is denigration. |
“Corticosteroid-free” | Prohibited. These substances are excluded from cosmetics anyway: the claim presents legal compliance as an advantage. |
“Preservative-free” | Possible, only if no ingredient plays that role, including a multifunctional ingredient. |
“Fragrance-free” | Possible, only if no ingredient has a perfuming function, even a fragrant plant extract. |
“Alcohol-free” on a family mouthwash | Acceptable: the information genuinely helps the choice. |
“Free from ingredients of animal origin” | Acceptable if accurate, as it is useful to vegan consumers. |
“Free from controversial preservatives” | Avoid: the denigration is the same, only the wording changes. |
“With aloe vera” | Possible if aloe vera is present in a quantity consistent with the way it is highlighted. |
“Enriched with hyaluronic acid, 24-hour hydration” | Possible if the effect is demonstrated by a test on the finished product, not just by the raw material data sheet. |
“Hypoallergenic” | Possible only if the product was designed to minimise the allergy risk, and this low potential is demonstrated. |
These verdicts are based on the European Commission's technical document on claims, which includes an annex dedicated to “free from” and “hypoallergenic” claims, applied since 1 July 2019.
The logic behind these verdicts
All these answers follow from the same six criteria. Once you have them in mind, most cases settle themselves.

The 6 criteria every claim must meet
Two of them explain most refusals of “free from” claims: legal compliance, which prohibits taking credit for the absence of a substance that is already banned, and fairness, which prohibits denigrating an authorised ingredient. For “with” claims, truthfulness is what counts: the ingredient must be present, at a dose that justifies the way it is presented.
The “hero” ingredient trap
Highlighting an ingredient creates an expectation. If the visual shows a close-up of a cut aloe vera leaf and the ingredient sits at the end of the INCI list, as a trace, the consumer is misled, even if not a single word is false.
The same logic applies to the effect: attributing a benefit to an ingredient assumes it is used at a concentration able to produce it. The supplier's documentation can be a starting point, but it does not demonstrate the efficacy of your formula.
Good habit: for each highlighted ingredient, record in the file its concentration, the reason it is highlighted and, if it is linked to an effect, the evidence connecting it to the finished product.
Validating a claim before printing it
Write the exact claim, as it will appear on the label, the website and social media.
Test it against the six criteria, asking for each whether an inspector could challenge it.
Gather the appropriate evidence: a test on the finished product for an efficacy promise, the composition for a “free from” or “with” claim.
File the evidence in the PIF. Article 11 of the Regulation requires the proof of claimed effects to be kept there.
Check consistency across all media. A claim removed from the label but still present on a retailer's product page remains a claim.
A claim that fails this filter should not be reworded to “get through”: it should be dropped or backed by new evidence.
Have your claims reviewed
Reguloo reviews your labels and marketing materials, flags risky wording and proposes compliant alternatives, substantiated in your PIF. Contact us or discover our cosmetic regulatory consulting.




Comments