CPSR: who can sign the safety assessment of a cosmetic?
Your manufacturer offers you a "ready-made" safety report. An online provider promises one within 48 hours. An acquaintance "in the trade" offers to sign it.
Before accepting, one question decides everything: is the person signing allowed to do so? A report signed by an unqualified person is worthless in an inspection, and you are the one held accountable.
The short answer
• The CPSR is signed by a qualified safety assessor (Article 10 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009).
• A university degree in pharmacy, toxicology, medicine or a similar discipline is required, or a course recognised as equivalent.
• The assessor signs Part B, which concludes on the safety of the product.
• The Responsible Person remains responsible for the product, even with a signed report.
1. What the Regulation actually says
In short: the safety assessment is reserved for a person whose university training is defined by the text.
Article 10(2) of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 provides that the safety assessment (Part B of Annex I) is carried out by a person holding a diploma or other evidence of formal qualifications awarded on completion of a university course of theoretical and practical study:
in pharmacy;
in toxicology;
in medicine;
or in a similar discipline;
or a course recognised as equivalent by a Member State.
The text requires no approval, no registration on an official list and no laboratory status. It requires a qualification, and that this qualification appears in the report.
2. CPSR, safety report, Part B: key terms
CPSR: Cosmetic Product Safety Report, the central document of the PIF.
Part A: the safety information: composition, stability, microbiological quality, packaging, exposure, toxicological profile of the ingredients, undesirable effects.
Part B: the assessment itself: conclusion, warnings and instructions of use, scientific reasoning, assessor's credentials and signature.
Safety assessor: the qualified person who writes and signs Part B.
Responsible Person: the person established in the EU who places the product on the market and answers for its compliance.

The two parts of the safety report under Annex I
Part A can be prepared with the help of others. Part B is written, justified and signed by the assessor. It carries their scientific responsibility.
3. Which qualifications are accepted?
In short: pharmacy, toxicology and medicine are the three routes named by the Regulation. Beyond that, each Member State can recognise equivalent courses.

The qualifications set out in Article 10(2)
In France, an order of 25 February 2015 specifies the courses recognised as equivalent for acting as a safety assessor for cosmetic products.
The "similar discipline" remains the grey area: a related scientific background (chemistry, biology…) is not always enough. If in doubt, ask the assessor to justify their background, and keep that justification in the PIF.
Common mistake: confusing experience with qualification. Ten years in formulation do not replace the degree required by Article 10.
4. What the signature commits to, and what it does not
The assessor is responsible for their scientific reasoning: the conclusion they draw from the available data, the warnings they impose and the conditions of use they set.
But it is the Responsible Person who must ensure that the product has undergone a safety assessment before being placed on the market (Article 10(1)), and who answers for its compliance to the authorities.
In practice, a signed report does not replace:
the rest of the PIF (manufacturing, proof of claims, animal testing data);
compliant labelling;
CPNP notification;
updating the report when the formula, the data or the regulation change.
5. Four situations to watch
1. A report with no name or credentials. Part B must name the assessor and justify their qualification. Otherwise the report is incomplete.
2. A "standard" report reused. A common base is not enough: each product, with its fragrance, shade and packaging, has its own report.
3. A report disconnected from the finished product. The conclusions must rely on data for the product actually sold: its formula, stability, microbiological quality and packaging.
4. A report never updated. Article 10 requires the report to be kept up to date with information gathered after placing on the market, such as undesirable effects. A new ingredient restriction also requires a review.
6. How to check your assessor: 5 questions
What is their degree, and in which discipline?
Do their name and credentials appear in Part B?
Does the report cover your exact formula, in percentages?
Does it rely on data for your finished product (stability, microbiology, packaging)?
Who updates the report if the formula or the regulation changes?
A vague answer to any of these questions deserves a second opinion.
What Reguloo takes care of
The safety report, Parts A and B, drawn up and signed by a qualified assessor within the meaning of Article 10.
Review of an existing report, to check it will stand up to an inspection.
The full PIF, labelling and CPNP notification.
Updates to your reports when the regulation changes.
In doubt about your safety report?
Send us your CPSR: we check the signature, the credentials and its consistency with your product.
Frequently asked questions
Can my manufacturer sign the CPSR?
Yes, if the person signing holds the qualification required by Article 10. Being the manufacturer is not enough: the assessor's qualification is what counts.
Can a formulation chemist sign a CPSR?
Not automatically. Chemistry is not named by the Regulation; it can only fall under the "similar discipline" or an equivalence recognised by a Member State.
Must the assessor be based in the EU?
The Regulation does not require it. However, the report must be accessible, in a language easily understood by the authority, at the Responsible Person's address shown on the label.
Must the CPSR be redone for every formula change?
It must be reviewed: a new formula is a new product to assess. A change of fragrance or packaging can also change the conclusion.
Can the Responsible Person also be the assessor?
Yes, if they hold the required qualification. The two roles remain distinct: one assesses, the other answers for the compliance of the product.
Need a qualified safety assessor?
Reguloo draws up your safety reports, builds your PIFs and supports you through to notification. Contact us: reply within 48 working hours.
Learn more: our product information file service, our EU Responsible Person service and our regulatory advice.
Sources
Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Article 10 and Annex I, consolidated version (EUR-Lex)
Commission Implementing Decision 2013/674/EU: guidelines on Annex I (EUR-Lex)
Order of 25 February 2015 on the professional qualification of cosmetic product safety assessors (French Official Journal, 17 March 2015)




Comments