Definition of a cosmetic: the 3 criteria to know whether your product is one
Updated: 4 hours ago
A toothpaste is a cosmetic. A “sanitising” hand gel is not. A cream “for blemish-prone skin” is one; a cream that “treats acne” no longer is. Between the two, the composition is sometimes identical: it is the legal definition that makes the difference.
This status determines everything else: safety report, PIF, Responsible Person, CPNP notification, labelling. Getting the category wrong means applying the wrong rules to your product.
What the law says
Article 2 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 defines a cosmetic product as “any substance or mixture intended to be placed in contact with the external parts of the human body (epidermis, hair system, nails, lips and external genital organs) or with the teeth and the mucous membranes of the oral cavity with a view exclusively or mainly to cleaning them, perfuming them, changing their appearance, protecting them, keeping them in good condition or correcting body odours”.
In France, the Public Health Code repeats this definition in article L. 5131-1. It breaks down into three criteria, all of which must be met.

Three criteria, all mandatory
The most difficult criterion: the function
The first two criteria are easy to check. The third requires more attention, because it depends as much on the formula as on the way the product is presented.
A product presented as having properties for treating or preventing disease is a medicinal product “by presentation”, whatever its composition. The words “heals”, “cures”, “treats” or the name of a condition are enough to tip a product over. If in doubt between the two statuses, medicinal product rules apply.
Good habit: describe what the product does for the appearance or comfort of the skin, never what it would do against a disease.
Ten products, ten verdicts
Product | Status |
Toothpaste | Cosmetic |
Anti-dandruff shampoo | Cosmetic |
Sunscreen | Cosmetic |
Tooth whitening up to 0.1% hydrogen peroxide | Cosmetic sold freely; from 0.1% to 6%, reserved for dentists |
Cream “for blemish-prone skin” | Cosmetic |
Cream that “treats acne” | Medicinal product by presentation |
Hand gel claiming a disinfecting action | Biocide |
“Beauty” food supplement | Food |
Tattoo ink | Not a cosmetic, regulated under REACH |
Head lice product | Medicinal product, medical device or biocide, depending on its mode of action |
Borderline products
Some products remain difficult to classify. The European Commission publishes a manual on borderline products, listing cases examined by Member State authorities. It is not binding, but it reflects the common position of the authorities and serves as a reference.
If you are launching a product on the border between two categories, its status must be settled before development: it determines the formula, tests, file and claims.
Frequently asked questions
Can a product be both a cosmetic and a medicinal product?
No. A product falls into a single category. When a product meets both the definition of a cosmetic and that of a medicinal product, medicinal product rules apply.
Is a pure vegetable oil sold for the skin a cosmetic?
Yes. A single substance can be a cosmetic, as long as it is intended for cosmetic use. All the obligations of the Regulation apply.
Is an accessory, such as a brush or a massage roller, a cosmetic?
No. An object is neither a substance nor a mixture. It falls under other rules, such as general product safety.
Who decides a product's status in case of disagreement?
The national authorities, under the supervision of the courts. In France, the DGCCRF oversees cosmetics and the ANSM oversees medicinal products.
Unsure about your product's status?
Reguloo analyses your product, its formula and its claims, and tells you which regulatory framework applies before you start development. Contact us.
Going further: discover our cosmetic regulatory consulting, our Product Information File (PIF) service and our online compliance test.
Sources
Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products, article 2 (EUR-Lex)
French Public Health Code, article L. 5131-1 (Légifrance)




Comments