top of page

Cosmetic safety tests: which are mandatory and why

23 hours ago
3 min read

Updated: 3 hours ago

“Which tests do I need before selling a cosmetic?” It is one of the first questions brand founders ask. The answer often surprises: the EU Regulation does not set any list of mandatory tests. It does, however, require a safety assessment, which cannot be carried out without certain data. It is this data that makes some tests essential.


The principle

The cosmetic product safety report (Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009) must bring together information on stability, microbiological quality, packaging, exposure and the toxicology of the ingredients. Tests serve to produce this information. Their number and nature therefore depend on the product.


The categories of safety tests for a cosmetic

Which tests, and what for?


Tests essential for every product


Without them, the assessor cannot conclude that the product is safe.


Test

What it demonstrates

Stability

The product keeps its characteristics over time and under various storage conditions. It underpins the shelf life or the period after opening.

Microbiological quality

The finished product meets microbial contamination criteria suited to its use.

Packaging compatibility

The formula and its container do not interact: no migration, deformation or loss of efficacy.

Physical/chemical characteristics

Appearance, pH, viscosity, density: the product's identity card, used to check each batch.


Tests that depend on the formula


Preservative efficacy


The “challenge test” consists of deliberately contaminating the product to check that its preservation system eliminates micro-organisms. It is the rule for products containing water. Some products with a low microbiological risk, such as anhydrous or high-alcohol products, may be exempted with justification, according to ISO 29621.


Assays and trace testing


When an ingredient is subject to a maximum concentration, or when a raw material may bring impurities, analyses make it possible to demonstrate that the limits are respected.


Tests that prove a claim


A promise on the label must be proven. Efficacy tests (hydration, firmness, volume…) and the sun protection factor, measured using standardised methods, are part of this.


Tolerance tests on volunteers, often called “patch tests”, are not required by the Regulation. They serve to confirm the good tolerance of a product already assessed as safe, and to substantiate statements such as “dermatologically tested”. The assessor may nevertheless recommend them for certain products or populations.


Example: a brand launches an eye contour cream and wants to write “ophthalmologically tested”. Without a tolerance study carried out under the supervision of an ophthalmologist, the statement is misleading, even if the product is perfectly safe.


What is prohibited


Since 11 March 2013, the EU has banned placing on the market cosmetics whose finished product or ingredients have been tested on animals to meet the requirements of the Regulation (article 18). Safety relies on existing data and validated alternative methods.


What drives the budget


The cost of testing depends on the product type, whether the formula contains water, the number of sizes and containers, and above all the claims. A moisturising cream with no particular claim requires far fewer studies than an anti-ageing product claiming quantified results. Defining your claims in the specifications is the best way to control this budget.


Build your test plan


Reguloo defines with you the tests your product needs, no more and no less, and integrates them directly into your safety report and PIF. Contact us.


Sources



Comments


bottom of page